Best Pizza in Upper East Side

Serafina Fabulous Pizza offers a cozy, cheerful atmosphere, perfect for a relaxing meal. While some pasta dishes have received mixed reviews, their delicious thin-crust pizzas, like the Buffalo Mozzarella, are a definite highlight and a must-try. The service is generally attentive, contributing to a pleasant dining experience.

Mimi's Pizza delivers an authentic New York pizza experience, immediately greeting patrons with an amazing aroma and a display of tempting slices. Known for its perfect crust—crispy, never soggy—and balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio, their square slices, including the standout pesto vodka, are highly recommended. Despite a compact space, the flavors are varied and consistently high quality.

Donna Margherita transports diners straight to Italy with its warm, lively, and welcoming ambiance, complemented by incredible hospitality from the owner and staff. This charming spot excels in Neapolitan-style pizza, with the Burrata pizza often hailed as the best, featuring an incredible sauce and exceptional crust. Beyond pizza, guests rave about other high-quality Italian specialties like the Octopus salad and Pasta with clams.

San Matteo is a beloved go-to for consistently excellent Neapolitan-style pizza, cooked to perfection in a wood-burning oven, offering an ideal balance of crisp and chew. Beyond their never-disappointing pizzas, the authentic NYC Italian experience extends to delicious pasta dishes and yummy appetizers. The staff are known for being friendly, welcoming, and providing great recommendations in a lovely, inviting environment.

Village Square Pizza is a fantastic spot for a quick bite, offering a wide array of interesting flavors and toppings, making it ideal for groups. Highlights include their phenomenal Pepperoni and delightful Margherita slices, both featuring a fresh, cheesy, and crispy crust with great sauce flavor. Their amazing deep-dish crust and cozy, local vibe further solidify its reputation as a top UES pizza destination.