Best Pizza in Key Biscayne

Tucked away near the Miami Seaquarium, Sunset Point Wood Fired Pizzeria is a hidden gem celebrated for its authentic Neapolitan-style pies. Their wood-fired oven imparts a subtle smoky flavor to the perfectly baked, light, and crispy crust, complemented by fresh, high-quality ingredients and outstanding tomato sauce. Beyond the amazing pizzas, don't miss their delicious Sicilian cannoli in a relaxing atmosphere with friendly staff.

Tutto Pizza & Pasta offers an outstanding Italian dining experience in a buzzy setting with a welcoming patio. Their brick-oven pizzas, like the excellent sausage and peppers pie with its thin, perfectly cooked crust, are a major draw. Beyond pizza, guests rave about world-class Italian classics such as the lasagna and chicken parmesan, all served with terrific attention to detail by their professional staff.

D'LITE Bistro & Bakery stands out for its commitment to healthy, fresh, and clean ingredients, making it a fantastic spot for guilt-free indulgence. While offering a range of nutritious options, their Michaelangelo cauliflower crust pizza is a particular highlight, alongside their spectacular natural juices and acai bowls. The charming bistro provides outstanding, personalized service in a cute setting with a beautiful outdoor area.

Sir Pizza is a true Miami staple, beloved for its distinctive square-cut, thin-crust pies where toppings extend all the way to the edge. Many locals consider it the best pizza in Key Biscayne, often recommending it with a side of their famous ranch sauce. While service experiences can vary, its unique flavor profile and nostalgic appeal keep customers coming back for years of reliable goodness.

Miami Slice Key Biscayne is gaining a reputation for its massive, uniquely flavored pizzas, often hailed as some of the best in Miami. Standout options include the "insane" hot honey pepperoni and creative choices like the Leek on Bacon, all featuring a consistently crispy crust and robust flavor. Despite some minor service quirks, the quality and distinctive taste make it a must-try for serious pizza enthusiasts.