Best Pizza in Chelsea

A true NYC institution since 1964, NY Pizza Suprema is widely acclaimed as a midtown favorite, offering an impressive selection of around 25 different pies, including vegan options. Patrons rave about the perfectly thin, foldable crust and the tangy, flavorful sauce that graces every slice. Don't miss their standout Burrata or White slice with garlic for an unforgettable experience.

Andiamo Pizza is a bustling, family-operated counter-serve known for its solid, traditional New York slices and quick service, even during late-night hours. This clean and well-organized spot offers a great variety, from classic cheese and pepperoni to more inventive options like chicken with vodka sauce or a hearty meat lovers pie. The dough is consistently praised for being perfectly thin and crispy, providing an excellent base for their flavorful toppings.

Baggios Pizzeria is a delightful hidden gem in Chelsea, celebrated for its welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and vibrant artwork. Guests are consistently impressed by the perfectly crispy thin crust, which serves as an ideal foundation for their creative and delicious offerings, including unique lasagna and tie-dye pizzas, as well as a standout vodka slice. This spot offers great vibes and a memorable dining experience where you can relax and pay after your meal.

Located within the bustling Chelsea Market, Filaga brings authentic Sicilian pizza to New York with its focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients and a perfectly executed crust. Their signature 72-hour fermented dough results in a light, crispy, and flavorful base, reminiscent of traditional Sicilian village recipes. While seating can be limited, it's an ideal spot to grab exceptional slices like the Inferno, Zucchini, or a rich burrata slab, all boasting that distinct brick-oven flavor.

Don Giovanni offers a charming experience with its coal-fired Neapolitan pizzas and a selection of classic Italian entrees, complete with inviting sidewalk tables. Reviewers consistently highlight the warm welcome and friendly, attentive service, even during busy times. Their pizzas are lauded for a crispy, thin, and foldable crust, embodying the quintessential NYC pizza experience, with the Caprina and pepperoni being popular choices alongside delicious pasta and chicken marsala.